Examining Mackinder's Heartland Thesis
Now with 100% less references to 'yellow peril', 'struggle between German and Slav', and 'Asiatics'.
Halford Mackinder's 'Heartland Thesis ' is, rightly or wrongly, one of the foundational theories of modern geopolitics. Beginning from basic assumptions about terrain's impact on human societies, The Heartland Thesis reasons out a theory of worldwide dimensions (literally).
This video attempts to sketch out the theory's reasoning, put his thought into proper historical and political context, assess the Thesis' recommendations and address a few criticisms of his theory.
For the record, I don't buy the criticisms that a) the Thesis has become irrelevant in the post-nuclear world, and b) that speculating about this stuff is somehow analogous to agreeing with Lebensraum or whatever (in fact, Mackinder intended his theory to help defend democracy).
All errors are my own.
SOURCES:
Mackinder, 'Democratic Ideals and Reality'
Mackinder, 'The Geographical Pivot of History'
Mackinder, 'The Round World and the Winning of the Peace', Foreign Affairs
Dugan A. 'Mackinder and His Critics Reconsidered', The Journal of Politics
Gray C. 'In Defence of the Heartland', Comparative Strategy
Kaplan R, The Revenge of Geography
ATTRIBUTIONS:
Google Maps: for the maps.
Google Image Search: approximate borders of Imperial Russia, USSR, Nazi Germany.
Google Search: for China's 'Belt and Road Initiative'.
Wikipedia: for populations and basic historical cross-checking.
I do accept responsibility for winging the boundaries of the European colonial empires (sorry Port Arthur, Tsingtao and Port Edward; sorry for French Djibouti and French India etc etc etc.)
Made using Powerpoint 2013.
Видео Examining Mackinder's Heartland Thesis канала Strategy Stuff
Halford Mackinder's 'Heartland Thesis ' is, rightly or wrongly, one of the foundational theories of modern geopolitics. Beginning from basic assumptions about terrain's impact on human societies, The Heartland Thesis reasons out a theory of worldwide dimensions (literally).
This video attempts to sketch out the theory's reasoning, put his thought into proper historical and political context, assess the Thesis' recommendations and address a few criticisms of his theory.
For the record, I don't buy the criticisms that a) the Thesis has become irrelevant in the post-nuclear world, and b) that speculating about this stuff is somehow analogous to agreeing with Lebensraum or whatever (in fact, Mackinder intended his theory to help defend democracy).
All errors are my own.
SOURCES:
Mackinder, 'Democratic Ideals and Reality'
Mackinder, 'The Geographical Pivot of History'
Mackinder, 'The Round World and the Winning of the Peace', Foreign Affairs
Dugan A. 'Mackinder and His Critics Reconsidered', The Journal of Politics
Gray C. 'In Defence of the Heartland', Comparative Strategy
Kaplan R, The Revenge of Geography
ATTRIBUTIONS:
Google Maps: for the maps.
Google Image Search: approximate borders of Imperial Russia, USSR, Nazi Germany.
Google Search: for China's 'Belt and Road Initiative'.
Wikipedia: for populations and basic historical cross-checking.
I do accept responsibility for winging the boundaries of the European colonial empires (sorry Port Arthur, Tsingtao and Port Edward; sorry for French Djibouti and French India etc etc etc.)
Made using Powerpoint 2013.
Видео Examining Mackinder's Heartland Thesis канала Strategy Stuff
Показать
Комментарии отсутствуют
Информация о видео
Другие видео канала
The Naval Strategy of Alfred Thayer MahanMackinder's Heartland Theory (AP Human Geography)The Strategy of EurasianismThe Grand Strategy of Japan, 1919 - 1941Defensive Strategies of the Roman EmpireThe Strategy of the Peloponnesian WarChinese Strategy Against the Northern Steppe, c.600BC-90ADThe Mongol Conquest of Song China, 1230s-1279CGSR Seminar Series | War in Space: Strategy, Spacepower, GeopoliticsUS Strategy in Latin America, 1939 - 1949Sir Julian Corbett, Limited War, and a Strategy for Maritime StatesThe Strategy of GeoeconomicsThe Geopolitics of the Mughal EmpireNoam Chomsky: I would vote for Jeremy Corbyn (EXTENDED INTERVIEW) - BBC NewsnightReview: Last War of the World-Island by Alexander DuginSpykman's Rimland Theory (AP Human Geography)What Are The World's Oldest Borders?The Strategy of Machiavelli2020 Issues in National Security Lecture Series: John Maurer on Alfred Thayer MahanUnion Strategy During the American Civil War