Tamron 28-200 Lens Comparison (vs Sony 24-105 + Canon 70-300)

In this video I do an in-depth comparison of the Tamron 28-200 f2.8-5.6 Di III RXD lens to the Sony and Canon lenses I use to see if I can replace both of them with the Tamron and still deliver good quality.

00:00 Intro
03:18 Image Review
06:46 Side by Side Comparisons

My current setup:
- Sony a7r3
- Sigma 14-24 f2.8 DG DN ART
- Sony 24-104 f4 G OSS
- Canon 70-300 f4-f5.6 L IS USM + Metabones adapter

One important thing I didn't mention is lack of built-in image stabilization or a AF/MF switch on the Tamron lens. Neither of those matters much for me since the a7r3 has stabilization and you can program a button to switch focus mode.

RAW images and side by side views: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1z-vzFHIejjM7wANajF1qZ7Hq9pW-xGec?usp=sharing

Mads Peter Iversen's video comparison of this Tamron lens to a very similar setup: https://youtu.be/MgjvBQ16HE0

In my opinion, the a7r3 + a good ultrawide lens + the Tamron is one of the top two options out there for a landscape photographer who does a lot of hiking.

The other setup I mentioned that I would highly recommend exploring is Nikon Z7 ii + 14-30 + 24-200.
Dave Morrow's thoughts about switching to it from his Nikon d810: https://youtu.be/oR8tdNdB3wY
Felix Jorgenfelt's review of this setup playlist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5xDIJmtijCg&list=PLl4Vprw0oaRxQZu_zhpbGE3lSbyUfLlLy

Видео Tamron 28-200 Lens Comparison (vs Sony 24-105 + Canon 70-300) канала Yuriy Garnaev