We Were Right! Real Inner Misalignment

Researchers ran real versions of the thought experiments in the 'Mesa-Optimisers' videos!
What they found won't shock you (if you've been paying attention)

Previous videos on the subject:
The OTHER AI Alignment Problem: Mesa-Optimizers and Inner Alignment: https://youtu.be/bJLcIBixGj8
Deceptive Misaligned Mesa-Optimisers? It's More Likely Than You Think...: https://youtu.be/IeWljQw3UgQ

The Paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/2105.14111
The Interpretability Article: https://distill.pub/2020/understanding-rl-vision/
Jacob Hilton's thoughts about what's going on: https://www.alignmentforum.org/posts/iJDmL7HJtN5CYKReM/empirical-observations-of-objective-robustness-failures?commentId=8f5B3skqocxJjK4mk
AI Safety Camp: https://aisafety.camp/

With thanks to my wonderful Patrons at http://patreon.com/robertskmiles :
- Gladamas
- Timothy Lillicrap
- Kieryn
- AxisAngles
- James
- Jake Fish
- Scott Worley
- James Kirkland
- James E. Petts
- Chad Jones
- Shevis Johnson
- JJ Hepboin
- Pedro A Ortega
- Clemens Arbesser
- Said Polat
- Chris Canal
- Jake Ehrlich
- Kellen lask
- Francisco Tolmasky
- Michael Andregg
- David Reid
- Peter Rolf
- Teague Lasser
- Andrew Blackledge
- Brad Brookshire
- Cam MacFarlane
- Craig Mederios
- Jon Wright
- CaptObvious
- Brian Lonergan
- Girish Sastry
- Jason Hise
- Phil Moyer
- Erik de Bruijn
- Alec Johnson
- Ludwig Schubert
- Eric James
- Matheson Bayley
- Qeith Wreid
- jugettje dutchking
- James Hinchcliffe
- Atzin Espino-Murnane
- Carsten Milkau
- Jacob Van Buren
- Jonatan R
- Ingvi Gautsson
- Michael Greve
- Tom O'Connor
- Laura Olds
- Jon Halliday
- Paul Hobbs
- Jeroen De Dauw
- Cooper Lawton
- Tim Neilson
- Eric Scammell
- Igor Keller
- Ben Glanton
- Tor Barstad
- Duncan Orr
- Will Glynn
- Tyler Herrmann
- Ian Munro
- Jérôme Beaulieu
- Nathan Fish
- Peter Hozák
- Taras Bobrovytsky
- Jeremy
- Vaskó Richárd
- Benjamin Watkin
- Andrew Harcourt
- Luc Ritchie
- Nicholas Guyett
- 12tone
- Oliver Habryka
- Chris Beacham
- Nikita Kiriy
- Andrew Schreiber
- Steve Trambert
- Braden Tisdale
- Abigail Novick
- Serge Var
- Mink
- Chris Rimmer
- Edmund Fokschaner
- April Clark
- J
- Nate Gardner
- John Aslanides
- Mara
- ErikBln
- DragonSheep
- Richard Newcombe
- Joshua Michel
- P
- Alex Doroff
- BlankProgram
- Richard
- David Morgan
- Fionn
- Dmitri Afanasjev
- Marcel Ward
- Andrew Weir
- Kabs
- Ammar Mousali
- Miłosz Wierzbicki
- Tendayi Mawushe
- Wr4thon
- Martin Ottosen
- Andy K
- Kees
- Darko Sperac
- Robert Valdimarsson
- Marco Tiraboschi
- Michael Kuhinica
- Fraser Cain
- Robin Scharf
- Klemen Slavic
- Patrick Henderson
- Hendrik
- Daniel Munter
- Alex Knauth
- Kasper
- Ian Reyes
- James Fowkes
- Tom Sayer
- Len
- Alan Bandurka
- Ben H
- Simon Pilkington
- Daniel Kokotajlo
- Yuchong Li
- Diagon
- Andreas Blomqvist
- Iras
- Qwijibo (James)
- Zubin Madon
- Zannheim
- Daniel Eickhardt
- lyon549
- 14zRobot
- Ivan
- Jason Cherry
- Igor (Kerogi) Kostenko
- ib_
- Thomas Dingemanse
- Stuart Alldritt
- Alexander Brown
- Devon Bernard
- Ted Stokes
- Jesper Andersson
- DeepFriedJif
- Chris Dinant
- Raphaël Lévy
- Johannes Walter
- Matt Stanton
- Garrett Maring
- Anthony Chiu
- Ghaith Tarawneh
- Julian Schulz
- Stellated Hexahedron
- Caleb
- Clay Upton
- Conor Comiconor
- Michael Roeschter
- Georg Grass
- Isak Renström
- Matthias Hölzl
- Jim Renney
- Edison Franklin
- Piers Calderwood
- Mikhail Tikhomirov
- Matt Brauer
- Mateusz Krzaczek
- Artem Honcharov
- Tomasz Gliniecki
- Mihaly Barasz
- Mark Woodward
- Ranzear
- Neil Palmere
- Rajeen Nabid
- Clark Schaefer
- Olivier Coutu
- Iestyn bleasdale-shepherd
- MojoExMachina
- Marek Belski
- Luke Peterson
- Eric Rogstad
- Eric Carlson
- Caleb Larson
- Max Chiswick
- Aron
- Sam Freedo
- slindenau
- Johannes Lindmark
- Nicholas Turner
- Intensifier
- Valerio Galieni
- FJannis
- Grant Parks
- Ryan W Ammons
- This person's name is too hard to pronounce
- contalloomlegs
- Everardo González Ávalos
- Knut Løklingholm
- Andrew McKnight
- Andrei Trifonov
- Aleks D
- Mutual Information
- Tim
- A Socialist Hobgoblin
- Bren Ehnebuske
- Martin Frassek
- Sven Drebitz
- Quabl
- Valentin Mocanu
- Philip Crawford
- Matthew Shinkle
- Robby Gottesman
- Juanchi

http://patreon.com/robertskmiles

Видео We Were Right! Real Inner Misalignment канала Robert Miles AI Safety