Загрузка страницы

Hermione vs Ginny, who should Harry have ended up with?

Video Edited by aginpro: http://aginpro.tumblr.com/
Music is Dumbledore's Farewell: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZihzr-23ww

Me reading a few comments here: https://youtu.be/TwHmFVdAx7M
and here: https://youtu.be/f_2sFNBUjVk

Frequent comments:
“Hermione would do anything for Harry and she was always there for him.”
Oh Sure, but I’m not questioning the fact that they are good friends. I just don’t think that means they are in love.

"Sirius Black did not betray Harry's parents, that was Peter Pettigrew."
I know that's what actually happened. But I was talking about the part earlier in the book where they discover it was Sirius. Or if you want to be picky, they discover it's believed to be Sirius.

"Why did you give Malfoy that voice?"
It's the voice Stephen Fry gives him in the audiobooks.

"Ginny only thinks of Harry as The boy who lived"
Not true, Ginny never refers to Harry in that way in any of the books.

"When Ginny first meets Harry she's excited, but before she finds out he's Harry Potter, she doesn't care about him."
I honestly have no idea how people can think this, there are only about 3 pages between the point Harry introduces himself to the Weasleys and Ginny finding out who he is. You know how many times Ginny is mentioned in those 3 pages, by name or otherwise? Zero!

"Hermione and Harry don't kiss in GoF, they only hug"
You're thinking of the film. That hug in the tent before the first task is a film only addition, in fact, Hermione isn't even in that scene in the book, I found it a very odd change myself. The kiss I was talking about is on the last page of the book, Hermione kisses him on the cheek when she says goodbye.

“In the movies…” or "I was talking about the movies."
I don’t care about them, this video is about the books. I know I’m playing clips from the movies the whole time, but that’s really only so you have something more interesting to look at. If you want to talk about something that happens in the movies, makes sure it happened in the books too.

"Rowling said..."
Covered in the video. But if you want me to go into a bit more detail, I really don't think what Rowling said is important. I only mentioned it in the video to try and save people telling me about it in the comments (fat lot of good that did!) Firstly the quotes from Rowling about how Harry should have ended up with Hermione are very vague, there isn't much reasoning given as to why she thinks this. She just says she made a mistake and that's it. Second just because Rowling said this doesn't change the books themselves if Rowling wanted to pull a George Lucas and re-release the books with a changed ending where Harry does end up with Hermione, maybe then it would be more important. But as of the time I'm writing this, that's not happened.

"This is just my opinion"
There's nothing wrong with this statement on its own. But please understand that saying this does not make your opinion immune to counter-arguments.

"Cho Chang and Victor Krum thought Harry and Hermione were a couple. Doesn't that suggest they should be together?"
Certainly not. In fact, that's a terrible reason for two people to get together. Krum accepted that the two of them were friends as soon as Harry told him. Also, did you understand the idea behind Cho's misreading their relationship at all? She jumped to that conclusion for no real reason. It's supposed to make us dislike her, not think she might have a point.

"Why is the music sad"
It was used for a sad scene in the films, but the music itself is just music.

"This video is mostly just your own opinion"
Well of course it is, it's my video.

"This video is biased"
The video is very much pro Harry and Ginny, but that doesn't mean it's biased. Unless you mean that it's very much in favour of one particular side, in which case yes it's biased but that's inevitable when giving an opinion about something.

“There is more evidence of Harry ending up with Ginny because it was written that way.”
I’m not sure what people are even implying here. Are they suggesting any evidence of Harry ending up with Ginny should be disregarded because whatever Rowling had in mind for an interesting and satisfying end to the books isn't important? Or are they saying that the points I make are not valid because they are regarding things that might not have happened if Rowling had had a different ending planned? The former seems a bit disrespectful to Rowling and the latter seems a lot like speculation. I mean couldn't I just as easily dismiss this hypothetical version of the books where he ends up with Hermione for exactly the same reason?

"I thought from the title that this video would be more neutral."
Okay so the video gave you something a bit different from what you were expecting, sometimes that happens. Some people have suggested that the title is clickbait or false advertising, but I just don't see how it is. It's a question, and the video provided MY ANSWER to that question.

Видео Hermione vs Ginny, who should Harry have ended up with? канала Buc Reviewer
Показать
Комментарии отсутствуют
Введите заголовок:

Введите адрес ссылки:

Введите адрес видео с YouTube:

Зарегистрируйтесь или войдите с
Информация о видео
14 мая 2015 г. 23:42:23
00:12:38
Яндекс.Метрика