German Snipers Never Expected M1 Garand's 8 Rounds To Outshoot Their Kar98k's 5 Round Bolt Action

German Snipers Never Expected M1 Garand's 8 Rounds To Outshoot Their Kar98k's 5 Round Bolt Action

November 17, 1944, Hürtgen Forest—Private James Whitmore gripped his M1 Garand as his squad advanced through frozen woodland toward German positions. American officers had assured him his 8-round semi-automatic rifle was tactically superior to the German Kar98k bolt-action rifles requiring manual operation between each shot. The mathematics seemed obvious: American riflemen could fire 8 rounds as fast as they pulled the trigger while Germans needed 4 separate bolt operations for the same number of rounds. At 7:30 AM, following artillery bombardment, 180 American riflemen attacked Hauptmann Franz Richter's company of 130 Germans defending fortified positions with trenches, machine gun emplacements, and barbed wire. American squad leaders, following doctrine emphasizing volume of fire, encouraged rapid Garand volleys for maximum suppression. Within minutes the assault stalled completely. Machine guns from prepared positions pinned attacking infantry and inflicted casualties faster than assault could overcome. After 2 hours of intense fighting with American casualties mounting and zero progress, the company commander ordered withdrawal. The attack failed. German Kar98k rifles from defensive positions had proven just as deadly—actually MORE deadly from American casualty perspectives—than attacking Garands. The circumstances of combat had completely neutralized the Garand's theoretical advantage. Position, cover, and MG-42 fire determined outcomes far more than individual rifle rates of fire, shattering assumptions underlying American infantry doctrine.

**What You'll Discover:**
• How 5.4 million M1 Garands were produced by 1945 versus Germany's 150,000 Kar98k rifles—yet German defensive doctrine emphasizing accurate deliberate fire overcame rate-of-fire advantages
• Why German 7.92x57mm ammunition standardization across rifles AND machine guns streamlined supply while Americans managed separate calibers
• The brutal lesson: attacking infantry facing prepared defensive positions were at disadvantages NO amount of semi-automatic fire could overcome—machine gun placement mattered more than rifle specs
• How German marksmanship training emphasizing careful aimed shots at extended ranges proved devastatingly effective when defenders had time and position advantages
• Why American doctrine de-emphasizing marksmanship in favor of volume fire created soldiers who fired rapid poorly-aimed volleys wasting ammunition compared to deliberate German riflemen
• Unteroffizier Hans Kleist's captured interrogation May 1945: "Both rifles worked well if you had ammunition and time to aim—the problem was American artillery would kill you before rifle comparison mattered"
• The shocking realization: American success came NOT from Garand superiority but from overwhelming artillery and air support suppressing German positions BEFORE infantry made contact
• How American artillery regiments fired thousands of rounds daily while German artillery in 1945 could barely fire hundreds—ammunition abundance determined outcomes, not rifle characteristics
• Why German soldiers feared American artillery bombardments far more than Garands—captured prisoners consistently cited supporting fire volumes, never rifle inadequacy
• Post-war US Army Ordnance report 1946 conclusion: Garand's semi-automatic advantage was "far less significant than assumed in prewar doctrine"—supporting weapons proved truly decisive
• The fundamental lesson military planners missed: infantry assault required artillery/mortar/machine gun suppression BEFORE assault—WWI lesson relearned through WWII casualties
• Private Whitmore's survival and reflection: "Good weapon, but I feared German machine guns and artillery more than rifles—that engagement was decided by supporting fire, not rifle performance"

Subscribe for untold WWII stories where theoretical weapon superiority meant nothing against defensive positions, revealing that logistics and combined arms mattered more than technology.

**TAGS:**
#WW2 #M1Garand #Kar98k #InfantryWeapons #HurtgenForest #WWIIRifles #BoltAction #SemiAutomatic #GermanInfantry #AmericanInfantry #InfantryTactics #CombinedArms #DefensivePositions #WWIICombat #RifleComparison #Mauser #SpringfieldArmory #30-06 #792x57mm #MachineGunFire #MG42 #SupportingFire #ArtillerySupport #TacticalDoctrine #Marksmanship #VolumeOfFire #FireSuperiority #PreparedDefenses #FortifiedPositions #SquadTactics #PlatoonTactics #104thInfantryDivision #Timberwolves #Wehrmacht #RhinelandCampaign #InfantryAssault #CasualtyRates #MilitaryDoctrine #LogisticsWarfare #AmmunitionSupply #IndustrialCapacity #WeaponEffectiveness #CombatAnalysis #PostWarAnalysis #MilitaryHistory #WWIIEurope #GermanDefense #AmericanOffensive #TacticalLessons #OperationalWarfare #FireAndManeuver #SuppressiveFire #CoordinatedAttack #InfantryWeapons #SmallArms

Видео German Snipers Never Expected M1 Garand's 8 Rounds To Outshoot Their Kar98k's 5 Round Bolt Action канала Sicily Reports