Backcountry Cooking: Twig Stoves: Practical or Novelty?
Backcountry Cooking: Twig Stoves: Practical or Novelty?
Can twig stoves serve a practical use in backcountry cooking? Let's fire up a twig stove and compare it to a typical white gas or propane/isobutane backpacking stoves to find out. We will compare options in terms of weight, cost, performance and convenience, and determine what practical role a twig stove can really play in the backcountry.
THE TWIG STOVES
In this video, I'm using a gasifier-type twig stove from Canway, purchased from Amazon for only $20. Here's a new similar version: https://amzn.to/3i165IQ
(Note that this stove has an open bottom, which could allow hot ash to spill out. Do not use this stove on a combustible surface.)
Solo Stove makes a similar gasifier twig stove with a solid bottom that avoids this problem. This Backpacker magazine recommended stove does come at a higher price, but can be purchased in 2 sizes:
Solo Stove Lite (1-2 people): https://amzn.to/31zmGLz
Solo Stove Titan (3-4 people): https://amzn.to/2yUSwX1
-------------------------------------------------------------------
OBSERVATIONS:
In this video, I compare a Canway gasifier twig stove to an MSR WhisperLite International white gas backpacking stove and a Jetboil propane/isobutane-powered backpacking stove. Here are some observations:
Advantages of Twig Stove:
- Cost: twig stove $20, WhisperLite $120 and Jetboil $100.
- Fuel: twig stove $0, WhisperLite $13/quart (inexpensive), Jetboil $5/canister (expensive)
- Volume: twig stove and Jetboil a bit smaller than WhisperLite and fuel bottle
- Quiet!
Disadvantage of Twig Stove:
- Not as fast as Jetboil to set up, start and get water boiling.
- Can't use during some fire bans (check with local authority).
- Dry wood can be more challenging to find in snow or rainy conditions.
- Leaves soot residue on cookware.
CONCLUSIONS:
Will I be replacing my Whisperlite or Jetboil with a twig stove for use in the backcountry? No. The Whisperlite can't be beat for reliable cooking on long backpacking trips, and a Jetboil can't be beat for convenience on short backpacking trips.
But I do enjoy the twig stove cooking experience enough to enough to bring it along as a second stove on canoeing or sea kayaking trips, where weight and volume are less of an issue. I really like how quiet it is and like and really enjoy the overall ambiance of cooking over burning wood.
What are your thoughts? Leave a comment below.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC91VZe7lFnny6RX2SdQV30Q?sub_confirmation=1
LET'S STAY CONNECTED:
Photography: http://www.bradmitchellphoto.com
Blog: http://bradmitchellphoto.com/blog
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/BradMitchellPhotography
Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service with these links, I may receive a small commission for the referral. There is no additional charge to you! Thanks for your support so I can continue to provide you with free content!
Thanks for your support!
Видео Backcountry Cooking: Twig Stoves: Practical or Novelty? канала Brad Mitchell Photography Outdoors
Can twig stoves serve a practical use in backcountry cooking? Let's fire up a twig stove and compare it to a typical white gas or propane/isobutane backpacking stoves to find out. We will compare options in terms of weight, cost, performance and convenience, and determine what practical role a twig stove can really play in the backcountry.
THE TWIG STOVES
In this video, I'm using a gasifier-type twig stove from Canway, purchased from Amazon for only $20. Here's a new similar version: https://amzn.to/3i165IQ
(Note that this stove has an open bottom, which could allow hot ash to spill out. Do not use this stove on a combustible surface.)
Solo Stove makes a similar gasifier twig stove with a solid bottom that avoids this problem. This Backpacker magazine recommended stove does come at a higher price, but can be purchased in 2 sizes:
Solo Stove Lite (1-2 people): https://amzn.to/31zmGLz
Solo Stove Titan (3-4 people): https://amzn.to/2yUSwX1
-------------------------------------------------------------------
OBSERVATIONS:
In this video, I compare a Canway gasifier twig stove to an MSR WhisperLite International white gas backpacking stove and a Jetboil propane/isobutane-powered backpacking stove. Here are some observations:
Advantages of Twig Stove:
- Cost: twig stove $20, WhisperLite $120 and Jetboil $100.
- Fuel: twig stove $0, WhisperLite $13/quart (inexpensive), Jetboil $5/canister (expensive)
- Volume: twig stove and Jetboil a bit smaller than WhisperLite and fuel bottle
- Quiet!
Disadvantage of Twig Stove:
- Not as fast as Jetboil to set up, start and get water boiling.
- Can't use during some fire bans (check with local authority).
- Dry wood can be more challenging to find in snow or rainy conditions.
- Leaves soot residue on cookware.
CONCLUSIONS:
Will I be replacing my Whisperlite or Jetboil with a twig stove for use in the backcountry? No. The Whisperlite can't be beat for reliable cooking on long backpacking trips, and a Jetboil can't be beat for convenience on short backpacking trips.
But I do enjoy the twig stove cooking experience enough to enough to bring it along as a second stove on canoeing or sea kayaking trips, where weight and volume are less of an issue. I really like how quiet it is and like and really enjoy the overall ambiance of cooking over burning wood.
What are your thoughts? Leave a comment below.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
SUBSCRIBE:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC91VZe7lFnny6RX2SdQV30Q?sub_confirmation=1
LET'S STAY CONNECTED:
Photography: http://www.bradmitchellphoto.com
Blog: http://bradmitchellphoto.com/blog
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/BradMitchellPhotography
Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service with these links, I may receive a small commission for the referral. There is no additional charge to you! Thanks for your support so I can continue to provide you with free content!
Thanks for your support!
Видео Backcountry Cooking: Twig Stoves: Practical or Novelty? канала Brad Mitchell Photography Outdoors
Показать
Комментарии отсутствуют
Информация о видео
11 августа 2018 г. 20:28:31
00:25:00
Другие видео канала
The ULTIMATE Wood Stove Comparison - Watch THIS Before you Buy a Wood Stove!My Twig Stove VideoUltralight Backpacking Stove Comparison: MSR vs. Alcohol vs. Esbit vs. Stove in a canBurning Wood Pellets in Wood Gas Stoves161. Easiest Tin Can Rocket Stove Hybrid - No Drill Required.Homemade Wood Gas Burning Stove Like Solo Stove for Camping - Secondary Combustion - Part-1The Truth About Gasification StovesGasifier Wood Stove TestOHUHU WOOD Burning Camp STOVE | Get It Right!Super Size Hobo StoveToo Expensive for a Gasifier Wood Stove?Ikea Hobo Stove VS Lixada Wood Gas StoveStoves for Bushcraft, Backpacking and Fun. Wood vs. Gas vs. Paraffin vs. Spirit.Camp Stoves - Backpacking 101 - Which one?Solo Stove Lite Review // Lightest Stove With Unlimited Fuel20 dollar eBay Stainless Steel Wood Gas Stove Field Use Review.Top 10 Best Wood Burning Stove for Camping & BackpackingSolo Stove vs Toaks Stove vs Firebox Nano. Twig Stove Showdown!World's Tiniest Twig Stove Meets Tiny Espresso Pot - Bushcraft Essentials Pocket Micro EDC StoveA New Design of Alcohol Backpacker Stove boils water faster than a Trangia