Do We Need Government? | Learn Liberty
Should government provide law enforcement? Most would argue that government is absolutely necessary for law enforcement. Prof. Edward Stringhman, however, argues that government may not even be necessary at all.
To come to this conclusion, Prof. Stringham asks a few important questions. First, if something is really important, does it logically follow that government should provide it? Second, are markets capable of providing law enforcement and security in the modern world? Third, how are disputes currently settled between people of different countries?
Looking at the first question, it doesn't seem to be the case that important things must be provided by a government. For instance, think about food. Food is necessary for life, and yet, markets do an excellent job of providing food to consumers.
Even if you're convinced that markets can provide important things, you may think law enforcement and security are a special case that markets are incapable of providing in a modern world. However, markets already enforce private rules and provide security. Disney World, Las Vegas, and malls all have private rules that are enforced by private security.
Accepting the arguments above, you may still be skeptical about market's abilities to settle disputes between different systems of rules or law. This, in fact, was Ayn Rand's primary reason for advocating a minimal state. Current interactions in the real world provide examples as to how markets resolve these disputes. Think about an international soccer game or international trade. In both instances, individuals are interacting across state boundaries, and are only subject to the jurisdiction of their own territory. In these situations, these individuals contract with the arbiters such as a soccer league or a private court to resolve disputes.
Credits: This lecture was delivered in 2009 at the Metropolitan State College of Denver School of Business, as part of the Exploring Economic Freedom Lecture Series, directed by Prof. Alexandre Padilla. This video was produced and directed by Scott Houck, and edited by Adrienne Christy. Video production provided by the Educational Technology Center at Metropolitan State College of Denver. Video used by LearnLiberty.org with permission.
Watch more videos: http://lrnlbty.co/y5tTcY
Видео Do We Need Government? | Learn Liberty канала Learn Liberty
To come to this conclusion, Prof. Stringham asks a few important questions. First, if something is really important, does it logically follow that government should provide it? Second, are markets capable of providing law enforcement and security in the modern world? Third, how are disputes currently settled between people of different countries?
Looking at the first question, it doesn't seem to be the case that important things must be provided by a government. For instance, think about food. Food is necessary for life, and yet, markets do an excellent job of providing food to consumers.
Even if you're convinced that markets can provide important things, you may think law enforcement and security are a special case that markets are incapable of providing in a modern world. However, markets already enforce private rules and provide security. Disney World, Las Vegas, and malls all have private rules that are enforced by private security.
Accepting the arguments above, you may still be skeptical about market's abilities to settle disputes between different systems of rules or law. This, in fact, was Ayn Rand's primary reason for advocating a minimal state. Current interactions in the real world provide examples as to how markets resolve these disputes. Think about an international soccer game or international trade. In both instances, individuals are interacting across state boundaries, and are only subject to the jurisdiction of their own territory. In these situations, these individuals contract with the arbiters such as a soccer league or a private court to resolve disputes.
Credits: This lecture was delivered in 2009 at the Metropolitan State College of Denver School of Business, as part of the Exploring Economic Freedom Lecture Series, directed by Prof. Alexandre Padilla. This video was produced and directed by Scott Houck, and edited by Adrienne Christy. Video production provided by the Educational Technology Center at Metropolitan State College of Denver. Video used by LearnLiberty.org with permission.
Watch more videos: http://lrnlbty.co/y5tTcY
Видео Do We Need Government? | Learn Liberty канала Learn Liberty
Показать
Комментарии отсутствуют
Информация о видео
Другие видео канала
![Did Laissez-Faire Policies Cause the Great Depression? #shorts](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/4CL0Hdjt9rI/default.jpg)
![Why America Revolted](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/74ahMSyqc10/default.jpg)
![The Hidden Truth About Supply and Demand](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hEUpTYPlTdE/default.jpg)
![The Hidden Truth Behind the US Healthcare System](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ETh7ijlh7DE/default.jpg)
![Behavioral Economics, Ep 3: Why Do We Make Bad Choices?- Learn Liberty](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/3REUuJClWRk/default.jpg)
![Prof. Antony Davies Answers the Most Googled Economics Questions (Part 1)](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/NVv_StQXHSI/default.jpg)
![Prof. Antony Davies: Was the Great Depression a Global Crisis? #shorts](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ihVsGC4t7Ks/default.jpg)
![The Broken Window Fallacy, Explained](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/hnwwkuCICms/default.jpg)
![Prosthetic Limbs: 3D Printers Making Superhero Hands for Children - Learn Liberty](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/63-Z8jfgsy8/default.jpg)
![Snowden: Good People Can do Bad Things #surveillance](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/YJJiz8STYk0/default.jpg)
![Section 230 Explained in 30 Seconds](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/cufGytIsVAE/default.jpg)
![When Bong Water Really Stinks – Drug War Stories (Ep. 2) with Alex Kreit | Learn Liberty](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/jRQaPaQ322o/default.jpg)
![The Most Important Invention You Never Thought About](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Zl0wr1915o/default.jpg)
![Is the FDIC bailout a bailout?](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/JHjAejxcKGw/default.jpg)
![The Original Purpose of the US Constitution - Learn Liberty](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/EiMOtS_lzZc/default.jpg)
![Snowden: Liberty is Freedom from Permission](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/LSkdQYju0rE/default.jpg)
![Snowden: They Are Watching You - The Shocking Truth #shorts](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/N26mn1LZG18/default.jpg)
![All The Cool Cops Are Doing It – Drug War Stories (Ep. 4) with Alex Kreit | Learn Liberty](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/afPsBsta6dw/default.jpg)
![A Cost-Benefit Approach to Public Policy](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/5AXyvVMLPrM/default.jpg)
![If You Give A Cop Some Coke – Drug War Stories (Ep. 1) with Alex Kreit | Learn Liberty](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/oNRYA4bO2-s/default.jpg)
![LibertyCon International 2022](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/9sqC2ifpj_E/default.jpg)