Ontario Court Warning on Using Text Messages as Evidence | Family Lawyers

#OntarioCourt #divorce #lawyer

Ontario Court Warning on Using Text Messages as Evidence | Family Lawyers

On Hearsay and Text Messages

The warning by the Ontario court in a recent case was straightforward: Family litigants need to be wary when including text messages and emails in their affidavit evidence.

In Chrisjohn v. Hillier the parents were in a custody battle over a their 3-year-old child. The father, who was the primary residential parent, brought an urgent motion to have the child returned to him. The mother had been withholding the child from him, even though she was only entitled to restricted access under a prior court order. She accused the father of having a substance abuse problem, and justified keeping the child because – based on her observations at a recent access exchange – she had concluded he was drunk or at least had been drinking when he took over the child.

https://familyllb.com/2021/06/24/on-hearsay-and-text-messages/

__________

RESOURCES & LINKS:

🌟 Learn more about our Family Law services:
https://www.russellalexander.com 🌟

"Top 5 questions about spousal support in Ontario, Canada":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX-25jPGfUw&t=5s

“How Base Child Support is Calculated”:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6y4McRjgZLs&t=9s

“How to fill out a financial statement“:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Joenqab3u8I

“Common Questions About Child Support in Ontario“:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eht4Lv852GY&t=67s

“How Long Does Child Support Continue in Ontario?”:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_STW0aGieY&t=6s

__________

Get your FREE guide on Child Access and Custody During the Pandemic: https://www.russellalexander.com/child-access-and-custody-during-the-pandemic

Grab a copy of our book on Amazon: The Path to a Successful Divorce: Russell Alexander's Guide to Separation, Divorce and Family Law (Canadian, Ontario):

Paperback Edition: https://www.amazon.ca/Path-Successful-Divorce-Alexanders-Separation/dp/0995936900/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid&sr

Kindle Edition: https://www.amazon.ca/dp/B0727NCRSP

__________

Our Areas of Practice:
https://www.russellalexander.com/practice/

Divorce Information Centre:
https://www.russellalexander.com/divorce-information-centre/

We serve all of Ontario

7 Ontario Locations:

Markham, Ontario
https://www.russellalexander.com/markham

Whitby, Ontario
https://www.russellalexander.com/whitby

Kawartha Lakes, Ontario
https://www.russellalexander.com/kawartha-lakes

Oshawa, Ontario
https://www.russellalexander.com/oshawa

Peterborough, Ontario
https://www.russellalexander.com/peterborough

Toronto, Ontario
https://www.russellalexander.com/toronto

Concord, Ontario
https://www.russellalexander.com/concord

__________

Find us on social:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/RussellAlexanderFamilyLawyers
Twitter: https://twitter.com/familyLLB
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/russellialexander
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/familyllb

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COOUEq1qtd8

#divorce #family #law #childsupport #blog #lawyer #collaborative #practice #divorceprofessional #publichealthagencyofcanada #sharedcustody #childcustody #divorce #childcustodylawyer #divorcecourt #divorcetips #marriage #tip

__________

00:15
'On Hearsay and Text Messages'
00:18
The warning by an Ontario court in a recent case was straightforward:
00:24
Family litigants need to be wary when including text messages
00:28
and emails in their affidavit evidence.
00:32
In a recent case of Hillier, the parents were
00:35
in a custody battle over their 3-year-old child.
00:39
The father, who was the primary residential parent,
00:43
brought an urgent motion to have the child return to him.
00:48
The mother had been withholding the child from him,
00:53
even though she was only entitled to restricted access under a prior court order.
01:01
She accused the father of having a substance abuse problem,
01:05
and justified keeping the child
01:08
because - based on her observations at a recent access exchange -
01:12
she concluded he was drunk or at least had been drinking when he took the child.
01:19
The father denied this, and in his affidavit materials filed on the motion
01:24
swore that he had not been drinking that day.
01:28
His own mother - with whom he lives - also attested to the same.
01:36
According to the mother's affidavit, she called the police that night,
01:40
and they had apparently confirmed "it was clear"
01:43
that he was "intoxicated" after attending at his home.
01:48
Problems with these assertions that under Canadian law of evidence,
01:53
this was actually "hearsay" evidence.
01:56
With narrow exceptions, the mother's affidavit evidence
02:01
should have stuck to what she actually knew, saw, or understood that day -
02:08
not her view of what the police thought or said.

Видео Ontario Court Warning on Using Text Messages as Evidence | Family Lawyers канала FamilyLLB