Загрузка страницы

Mr Straw-man declares a delusional victory

Believe in Jesus Ministries asked me to speak with this guy, MrBatman. I said I would. Then they wrote back to say:
"i just heard Mr BATMAN speak with an atheist, he didn't behave well, which i was unaware of"
To which I replied, "That won't matter. I'm used to it."
He showed up 40 minutes late, thinking he was several hours early, and (as you can see) BelieveInJesus Ministries was right about him. So I wrote back to say so:
"You were right. It didn't go well. He kept asking where the laws of the universe came from when the universe began. I repeatedly told him the universe never had a beginning, that material energy and universal wave function are both eternal; that an absolute nothingness is impossible. So something has to exist, and anything that exists has to have to have properties, and these are the properties it has to have in order to exist. Then he said, but where did those properties come from? Again I said, if it is eternal, then they didn't "come from" anywhere. After a few rounds of this, I told him that I had already corrected the first error in his premise four times yet he keeps going back to it. I told him I'm not going to correct the same error indefinitely. So there's no reason to continue.
As I was closing the browser, he said something along the lines of "turn or burn". So yeah, he didn't behave well. All he did do was cite the question-begging fallacy and tu quo quee fallacy (trying to paint my rationality as an opposing "belief system") on top of citing the already famously disproved arguments of irreducible and specified complexity. It was a nothing sandwich, a creatard 101 novice interaction of nothing but empty assertions without him having any idea of what he or I was talking about."
I went on to explain to BelieveInJesus Ministries that I was not going to make it public. The reason being that there was nothing to show. It was him saying, "you believe everything came from nothing when the universe began", and me saying, "No, I don't believe the universe began or that everything came from nothing".
This was repeated four more times over 25 minutes with a lot of other false assertions mixed in too. Since he couldn't get past the failure of his straw-man premise, there was no further we could go.
However, he seems to have recorded part of our interaction himself and uploaded a nine-minute segment of that here,
https://youtu.be/SLmRbAYscbs
Wherein he claims to have "destroyed" me. Amazingly he thinks he somehow scored a point! He even declared victory in a discussion where one could not even have a "victory". So now I have to upload the whole discussion just to show what a nothing sandwich it really was.

Видео Mr Straw-man declares a delusional victory канала AronRa
Показать
Комментарии отсутствуют
Введите заголовок:

Введите адрес ссылки:

Введите адрес видео с YouTube:

Зарегистрируйтесь или войдите с
Информация о видео
20 июня 2020 г. 7:31:48
00:25:18
Яндекс.Метрика